Is The Sinking City 2 a Direct Sequel?
Learn how The Sinking City 2 connects to the first game, whether prior play is required, and how its survival systems changed.
Quick answer
- It is a standalone sequel set in the same universe and 1920s era.
- You can start with The Sinking City 2 without finishing the first game.
- Arkham and Calvin Rafferty replace Oakmont and Charles Reed.
- Combat, limited inventory, safe rooms, and focused areas drive the new survival-horror structure.
The 15 Biggest Gameplay Differences
Compare the two games' world structure, investigation, combat, inventory, puzzles, and progression in direct gameplay footage.
Continue reading
These related The Sinking City 2 pages answer the next questions around this topic.
Standalone Sequel, Shared Universe
The Sinking City 2 is a standalone sequel in the same universe and 1920s time frame as the first game. It opens a new door into the same flooded mythology with a new central story, a new city, and a new protagonist. It does not continue one chosen ending from the 2019 game.
Calvin Rafferty takes the lead in Arkham, replacing Charles Reed and Oakmont. That separation lets returning players recognize the wider Lovecraftian setting while giving newcomers a complete starting point.
Do you need to play the first game?
You do not need to finish The Sinking City before starting the sequel. Frogwares designed Calvin's story so a new player does not miss a major plot event, and the standalone setup avoids selecting one of the first game's endings as canon.
Playing the original can still provide context for the series' tone and investigative roots. It remains optional background rather than required homework. The title carries continuity, while the play order does not.
The biggest gameplay changes
| System | The Sinking City | The Sinking City 2 |
|---|---|---|
| Core structure | Detective adventure with occasional horror combat | Survival horror centered on combat, exploration, and resource pressure |
| World | Broad open-city travel in Oakmont | Smaller, more focused areas in Arkham |
| Investigation | A central part of progression | Optional content that can reveal supplies, routes, lore, and tactical information |
| Puzzles | Investigation-led case work | More spatial locks, mechanisms, and key-item problems |
| Survival loop | Combat supports the detective structure | Limited inventory, storage, safe-room planning, scarce ammunition, dodging, and melee finishers |
The sequel puts survival decisions into the foreground. Weak-point combat and scarce ammunition make each encounter a resource choice, while limited inventory and storage create a stronger reason to plan from safe rooms.
Investigation still matters, though it is more concentrated and optional. Exploring can uncover supplies, alternate routes, secrets, lore, and information that changes how you approach danger. Players who enjoyed deduction can still pursue it without the main route using the exact structure of the first game.
What returning players should expect
Expect familiar cosmic-horror themes with a different rhythm. Arkham is divided into tighter areas, and progression emphasizes navigation, environmental mechanisms, combat decisions, and resource recovery. The new protagonist and independent plot mean prior character outcomes do not control the opening.
The sequel label describes the shared universe and creative lineage. It does not make the new campaign dependent on a save file, a recap, or a selected ending from the original.